Moved to files OMR compliant ?

[Johann Eisner]

After searching some files, I had errors with the MPDCenter that the file is not OMR compliant.
The reason of the error is that the file contains ~ moved to ... parts.
Have now read in the OMR definition the seventeenth time but found nothing about ~moved to files.

Question: Can a OMR compliant file now contain ~ moved to files or not?

Regards Johann

[Orion Pobursky]

After searching some files, I had errors with the MPDCenter that the file is not OMR compliant.
The reason of the error is that the file contains ~ moved to ... parts.
Have now read in the OMR definition the seventeenth time but found nothing about ~moved to files.

Question: Can a OMR compliant file now contain ~ moved to files or not?

Regards Johann

I would say yes. That said, non-compliance should not prevent inclusion in the OMR website.

[Willy Tschager]

After searching some files, I had errors with the MPDCenter that the file is not OMR compliant.
The reason of the error is that the file contains ~ moved to ... parts.
Have now read in the OMR definition the seventeenth time but found nothing about ~moved to files.

Question: Can a OMR compliant file now contain ~ moved to files or not?

Regards Johann

Good question. I also would say yes. Otherwise we would have to update the entire OMR with every library update. That's what ~movetos are for.

w.

[Michael Heidemann]

After searching some files, I had errors with the MPDCenter that the file is not OMR compliant.
The reason of the error is that the file contains ~ moved to ... parts.
Have now read in the OMR definition the seventeenth time but found nothing about ~moved to files.

Question: Can a OMR compliant file now contain ~ moved to files or not?

Regards Johann

I do not see a problem to handle these like all other kind of rules. If we create a model with "old" parts it is not a current model. So the check that MPDCenter does is at the point of adding the model to the OMR with the actual parts used. It is normal that some times later some parts are updated. So if you would upload the same model again the model needs to carry the actual references and not the old one.
I hope my words do not confuse you.
I still think this test needs to be done for fresh models.

cu
mikeheide

[Johann Eisner]

After searching some files, I had errors with the MPDCenter that the file is not OMR compliant.
The reason of the error is that the file contains ~ moved to ... parts.
Have now read in the OMR definition the seventeenth time but found nothing about ~moved to files.

Question: Can a OMR compliant file now contain ~ moved to files or not?

Regards Johann

I do not see a problem to handle these like all other kind of rules. If we create a model with "old" parts it is not a current model. So the check that MPDCenter does is at the point of adding the model to the OMR with the actual parts used. It is normal that some times later some parts are updated. So if you would upload the same model again the model needs to carry the actual references and not the old one.
I hope my words do not confuse you.
I still think this test needs to be done for fresh models.

cu
mikeheide

Do it already.
 If ~ Movedto parts are present, they will be replaced with the current version before uploading. 

Johann