+- LDraw.org Discussion Forums (https://forums.ldraw.org)
+-- Forum: Models and Parts (https://forums.ldraw.org/forum-18.html)
+--- Forum: Parts Authoring (https://forums.ldraw.org/forum-19.html)
+--- Thread: Tool to solve torus problems (/thread-11772.html)
Tool to solve torus problems - Stan Isachenko - 2014-01-07
I know there is great tool ring and cons, for working with Rings, and Cones, but i had problem with torus, is there tool to colculate toruses?
Re: Tool to solve torus problems - Max Martin Richter - 2014-01-07
I wrote an Excel file...it is Vera simple made. maybe somebody can adapt it to an commandline version. For the moment I have no time to write it by myself :-(
I can send you the excel file or attach it here. if you like...
/Max
Re: Tool to solve torus problems - Stan Isachenko - 2014-01-07
ok, attach it here i will try to use it
Re: Tool to solve torus problems - Max Martin Richter - 2014-01-07
Ok, here is a very simple calculation program... When I find the time, I'll try to write it as a commandline program.
(The original file extension is: .xls)
/Max
Re: Tool to solve torus problems - Stan Isachenko - 2014-01-07
thanks, but i do not understand how toruses work. I attache file where i need replace dat with primitive, it has 2,5 inside radius, and 10 outside. Using you tool i got t04o6000.dat from primgen, and when I used this primitive outer radius was great , but inner was not.
Re: Tool to solve torus problems - Max Martin Richter - 2014-01-07
Hehe, this was a bit tricky ;-)
What you need here is a reverse ratio tori.
If you use your outer radius of 10 and you now your inner radius is at 2.5, than it is a space of 7.5 LDU between.
Now you have to substract 7.5 from 2.5 . You will get -5 as an "imaginary real inner radius".
So you have to type 10 for the outer radius and -5 for the inner one in my excel sheet.
You will get Major: 2,5 and Minor: 7.5 -> Multiply by 2 you get 5 and 15. Just put these values in PrimGen2 and you will receive: r04o3000.dat
Fill the your rotation matrix with the major radius to stretch it the right way
Code:
1 0 -12.1 -8.562 0 2.5 0 0 0 -2.5 0 0 0 2.5 r04o3000.datStupid me - found a solution... Just calculate your high (in your example: 10.515 LDU and devide it by the ratio in this case) - you will get 3.505
/Max
Re: Tool to solve torus problems - Stan Isachenko - 2014-01-07
thanks a lot
Re: Tool to solve torus problems - Max Martin Richter - 2014-01-07
You're wolcome.
I'll install a compiler and give a try to write such a programme.
/Max
Re: Tool to solve torus problems - Max Martin Richter - 2014-01-08
Here is a somewhat beta version of a programme I wrote for this purpose.
I hope the calculation is correct in every case.
Just type, which torus you want and input its inner and outer radius.
Feel free, to report any bugs.
Next steps: exclude negative and wrong values for the input and add a calculator for y-scaling of tori.
(Please remove the .dat to use this programme)
/Max
Re: Tool to solve torus problems - Philippe Hurbain - 2014-01-08
It seems that if you make several calculations the programs keeps major/minor radii of 1st calculation... Calculated ratio is correct nonetheless.
Re: Tool to solve torus problems - Max Martin Richter - 2014-01-08
I will check this. I found the problem. The inner calculation was right, but there was a boolean, that wasn't reset when restart the calculation. Will be gone in the next version. I have also implement that the programme don't except negative values for the inner radius and checks if the outer radius is greater than the inner one.
Nevertheless I hope, that I can implement a y-scale area today, after this there will be more bug fixing (if necessary) and maybe I make a GUI, too.
/Max